Is Rental Property Insurance Cheaper Than Homeowners Insurance

The main contrast between rental property insurance (dwelling fire insurance) and homeowners insurance is the insured’s role.

Homeowners insurance is for home owners who reside in their property, while rental property insurance is for property owners who rent to tenants.

Homeowners vs rental insurance
Is rental insurance cheaper than homeowners: photo source (

Though their coverage is similar, there are notable distinctions.

What is homeowners insurance?

Homeowners insurance covers your home, belongings, and liability for injuries on your property.

It safeguards against incidents like falls, dog bites, or property damage.

It also aids with relocation costs if your home becomes uninhabitable.

Coverage applies to specific perils such as theft, fire, and storms, depending on your policy.

What is Renters Insurance?

Renters insurance safeguards you financially for damaged belongings and injuries on your property.

It covers personal items from perils like fire, theft, and storms.

The coverage includes personal property, liability, and “loss of use” for temporary relocations.

Despite landlord policies, renters insurance is often needed and can prevent misconceptions.

Some landlords may demand minimum liability coverage.

Always check your lease agreement for renters insurance requirements.

Differences in Coverage

Most mortgages require a standard homeowners policy, suitable for single-family homes.

Rental property owners who opt for homeowners insurance miss out on rental property insurance benefits.

Standard homeowners insurance lacks coverage for income loss after property damage.

Choosing homeowners insurance may save money initially, but landlords risk significant losses from property damage.

Loss of Rental Income

Homeowners’ policies lack rental income coverage, emphasizing the need for rental property insurance.

If a covered event forces a tenant out (e.g., fire), landlords lose potential rent during repairs.

With reters property insurance, a properly insured landlord receives compensation from the insurance company, ensuring fair rental income until the property is habitable again.

Covered Losses

Both policies cover damage from vandalism, theft, hail, wind, and fire to property structures.

Renters property insurance extends to items linked to the rental, including furnishings for laundry facilities.

Standard homeowners insurance covers personal belongings and pays for living elsewhere if the property is uninhabitable due to covered peril.

Both policies include liability coverage for guest accidents, covering medical expenses and legal defenses for the landlord or homeowner.


Both homeowners and rental insurance have limitations.

They don’t cover mechanical breakdowns, earthquakes, or floods.

Adding endorsements is necessary for specific coverage, like sewer backup.

Coverage amounts have restrictions too; for instance, stolen jewelry is usually covered up to $2000.

Renters property insurance excludes basic repairs, maintenance, and tenant belongings.

Policies vary, so consult your independent insurance agent for a tailored review and optimal coverage options.

Leave a Comment